Cold Case Breakthrough Identifies 'Montauk Mary' as Possible Victim of 'Thrill Killer'
Suffolk County investigators have identified Sofia Margherita Marrone, known as 'Montauk Mary,' as a potential victim of Richard Biegenwald, the Jersey Shore 'Thrill Killer,' using DNA evidence.


In 1978, Sofia Margherita Marrone was found shot dead near the Camp Hero radar tower in Montauk, New York, and remained an unidentified Jane Doe for nearly 50 years. On March 22, 1978, a U.S. Airman discovered her body in East Overlook Park, an area that later inspired Netflix's 'Stranger Things.' Marrone, originally from Pleasantville, New Jersey, was last seen leaving a hospital in Somers Point, New Jersey, on March 16, 1978, before being killed six days later (Fox News US, 2023). [1]
Suffolk County investigators identified Marrone using new DNA methods and believe she may have been a victim of Richard Biegenwald, also known as the Jersey Shore 'Thrill Killer.' Biegenwald, who died in prison in 2008, was convicted of killing six people between 1958 and 1982. The Suffolk County District Attorney noted that the bullet wounds found on Marrone's body matched the rare .22-caliber short rounds used by Biegenwald during his crimes (Fox News US, 2023). [1]
A contemporary witness reported seeing a man with a beard sitting in a gold-colored car with New Jersey plates near the Montauk park where Marrone's remains were found. Authorities noted that Biegenwald was known to have a beard and multiple vehicles, including one that roughly matched the witness' description. Despite this, Suffolk County authorities have not yet declared the case solved (Fox News US, 2023). [1]
Sofia Margherita Marrone was found shot dead near the Camp Hero radar tower in Montauk, New York, in 1978 and remained an unidentified Jane Doe for nearly 50 years. Investigators in Suffolk County, New York, identified her using new DNA methods and believe she may have been a victim of Richard Biegenwald, also known as the Jersey Shore 'Thrill Killer' (Source ID: 1). [1]
Advertisement
Marrone, of Pleasantville, New Jersey, was last seen leaving a hospital in Somers Point, New Jersey, on March 16, 1978. She was killed six days later at East Overlook Park in Montauk, with an autopsy revealing three bullet wounds in her legs and one to her chest (Source ID: 1). [1]
Biegenwald, who died in prison in 2008, was convicted of killing six people between 1958 and 1982. He had been known to pick up victims he encountered walking in towns along the Jersey Shore, and a contemporary witness reported seeing a man with a beard sitting in a gold-colored car with New Jersey plates near the Montauk park where Marrone's remains were found (Source ID: 1). [1]
In 1978, Sofia Margherita Marrone was found shot dead near the Camp Hero radar tower in Montauk, New York, and remained an unidentified Jane Doe for nearly 50 years. Suffolk County investigators identified Marrone using new DNA methods and believe she may have been a victim of Richard Biegenwald, also known as the Jersey Shore 'Thrill Killer' (1). Biegenwald, who died in prison in 2008, was convicted of killing six people between 1958 and 1982. A contemporary witness reported seeing a man with a beard sitting in a gold-colored car with New Jersey plates near the Montauk park where Marrone's remains were found (1). [1]
Marrone, of Pleasantville, New Jersey, was last seen leaving a hospital in Somers Point, New Jersey, on March 16, 1978. She was killed six days later at East Overlook Park in Montauk. The autopsy found three bullet wounds in her legs and one to her chest (1). Investigators in Suffolk County, New York, have identified Sofia Margherita Marrone as a Jane Doe previously known as 'Montauk Mary.' Marrone had been found shot dead in 1978. Now, police say they believe she may have been a victim of the Jersey Shore 'Thrill Killer' (1). [1]
Advertisement
The Suffolk County District Attorney noted that Biegenwald was using the same rare .22-caliber short rounds when he was arrested in 1983, adding to the suspicion that he was involved in Marrone's death (1). Authorities have not yet called the case solved, but they have identified Marrone along with five other cold case victims, highlighting the importance of continued investigation and the use of modern forensic techniques (1). [1]
Sources
Prepared with AI assistance from the cited sources.
The Cali Reporter newsletter
The stories worth your time.
California, the country, and what comes next. Join our free newsletter for reporting that keeps you informed.
More in U.S. News
- Driver Who Plowed Into Soccer Field Will Not Face Criminal Charges
A driver who fell asleep at the wheel and plowed a pickup truck into a youth soccer field in Wichita, Kansas, killing two people, will not face criminal charges, according to a report by the Sedgwick County District…
- Alleged Assault at NYC Protest Involving LGBTQ+ Activist
A woman claims she was assaulted by an LGBTQ+ activist during a protest outside Mount Sinai Hospital in New York City, according to a report by Fox News US.
- Animal Rights Activist Assaults NYC Horse Carriage Drivers
An animal rights activist was arrested after allegedly assaulting two horse-drawn carriage drivers in Central Park, according to police and union representatives.